Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Wound Ripped Open

Grief is a tidal wave that over takes you,smashes down upon you with unimaginable force,sweeps you up into its darkness,where you tumble and crash against unidentifiable surfaces,only to be thrown out on an unknown beach, bruised, reshaped...Grief will make a new person out of you,if it doesn't kill you in the making.
- Stephanie Ericsson
Some things don’t get better over time, the hole in your heart still remains.  Having a trial that continues to get postponed is one of the hardest, most emotional rollercoasters I have been on.  This is the second time the trial has been postponed and the third time the process has been delayed.  Emotionally, this has been one of the hardest things to do, especially being so far from family.  The not knowing, uncertainty of what is going on takes it’s toll on you.  It’s hard to explain what someone goes through unless they’ve gone through it themselves.  I don't think my friends understand, although they want to.  It's not something I want them to be able to fully comprehend and understand in the way I do.  Having a family member taken from you at the hands of others is hard; there is no closure.  It's not natural death or an accident.  Death is hard to rationalize when it's at the hands of others.

I can't lie - this week has been extremely hard on me.  And knowing that I'll go through this in another 3 months is also hard.  In three months, it will be a year since he was killed.  As much as I want to be with family at trial, the uncertainty of it is going to actually happen is in the forefront.  While I plan on being there at sentencing, I can't guarantee my presence at the trial.  But during each time the trial is expected to happen, I become OCD in my pursuit of information:  checking every news outlet and texting every relative for the latest information.  Honestly, I'm surprised my work hasn't said anything about my constant checking of news sources.  I'm thankful they understand what I'm going through and appreciate that I still take care of my tasks and responsibilities.  But I'm not certain my friends and team mates understand the toll this takes on someone.  The headaches, the stress, the tiredness, the need to just zone out; are all results of the stress of uncertainty that are hard to explain or comprehend to someone that hasn't been there.  Even trying to put words to my emotions is difficult.  There is no one specific emotion or term to describe it.  

Every time the wound is showing progress and healing, there is something that sets it back.  After losing my father, and all my grandparents, this has been the most difficult loss to date.  Part of that is being forced to remember the circumstances it happened.  At age 19, no healthy, young person should die, especially in the manner in which occurred.  I worry about his sisters and his parents.  His younger sister is very effected by what happened and I miss the person she used to be.  I was with her the day she was brought home from the hospital and am concerned she's not doing what makes her happy because of her grief.  I worry about his father, who was my father's youngest brother and I have the closest bond with in my family.  I know he's affected, but don't always know the right words to say or questions to ask.  His older sister is a lot like me; she keeps it in and doesn't' share her emotions.  All my other relatives, whom have been effected, how have they been doing?  My cousins and I have grown closer throughout this ordeal, but we don't discuss how this has effected us. 

I wish I could make this better for everyone, myself included.  I also wish my friends, team mates, and co-workers could feel the emotions I am going through but at the same time do not want them to experience this.  It's something I wish no person to experience, but have an understanding and empathy towards.  I want closure on what happened and those responsible to be punished.  It's a huge dichotomy containing many mixed emotions.  Closure and time are the only remedies in sight.  The sooner this can me over, the more time we have to heal and get back to living our lives in the way he would have wanted us to.

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Needs Assessment


Needs Assessment for Southwest Airlines

Southwest Airlines is known low cost airfare with excellent customer service.  They stress friendliness and individual pride in their mission statement, as well as providing employees with opportunities for learning and personal growth (Southwest Airlines website).  If training were to be offered to them, the first step is a needs analysis to understand the organizational culture, people targeted for training, and the tasks the training would cover.  Because training is such a broad area, the training focus has been narrowed to the goal of decreasing turn-around-time (TAT).  TAT is the time it takes from when an aircraft lands and docks at the gate to when it is pushed back from the gate and is ready to take off.  TAT a very important metric to airlines, since the more time an aircraft spends in the air, the more money it is making for the company.  Even within TAT, there are many factors to be considered in training:  luggage handling, people flow and movement, cabin readiness, maintenance issues, and flight connections to name a few (Leib, 2010).

Initially, the consultant would want to have conversations with key stakeholders and obtain their support for working with their teams in effort of reducing TAT.  The stakeholders would include:  the person who is championing (and paying for) the training and performance improvement activity and the directors of the respective departments baggage handling, gate representative, flight attendants, maintenance, and logistics.  Customers are also an important stakeholder and can provide information on improvements and the effects of training.  In the initial meeting, the consultant should review the charter and ask what each of the department’s goals and objectives are for the training and improvement activity to ensure the expectations are the same as yours.  The following questions should be asked so an understanding of the culture and each organization’s needs are met:

  • What are the expectations for the organization?
  • What regulatory policies and constraints exist?
  • Are all policies the same between airports, gates, and unions?
  • What competencies, skills, and constraints exist in hiring?
  • Are there any upcoming changes to the organization or technology used?
  • What are the workforce demographics?
  • How should the training or performance improvements be conducted? 
    • Who should do the training – internal or external?
    • What should be included?
    • Where the intervention should be held?
    • How long is available for training?
    • What are the ultimate goals?
    • Is there job progression available to employees?

After gaining a basic understanding of the culture, which should also be supplemented with research from articles, websites, and customer experiences, the following plan (with modifications as needed based on the previous conversation) could be proposed:

1.   Send surveys/questionnaires to the departments involved in the training and performance improvement activity.  This will be a quick and effective way to gather data from employees, especially if done electronically.  One of the downsides is a low rate of return and potentially only employees who are at one extreme or the other will return them (Noe, 2010).  Surveys should include the following topics with questions a mix of ranked, multiple choice, and short answer types (Morrison et al., 2007).

          a.  What issues exist with performing to expectations?
          b.  Do documented tasks exist and are they sufficient?
          c.  What motivates them to meet goals and expectations?

2.   Review the following data and records:
          a. TAT metrics and definition how it is measured
          b. Employee morale data
          c. Customer satisfaction metrics
          d. Lost luggage metrics
          e. Customer loading/unloading metrics
          f.  Value Stream Maps or past Process Maps
          g. Previous improvement activities
          h. Current training materials
          i.  Training records

3.  Perform interviews with limited people in each department.  The goal is to draw out answers through conversation and see if the employees offer additional insights, concerns, hypotheses or best practices throughout the conversation.  By allowing off-subject wandering, providing the original questions are answered, more data and information can be discovered that you wouldn’t have typically uncovered by sticking to a script or survey (Noe, 2010).

4.  If time is available, observation of people and tasks would be a great addition to understanding the organization, people, and tasks.  Observing the gate attendants, maintenance crews, customers, and watching the attendants ready the plane for the next trip could provide invaluable information.  The interactions between employees within the same department, working alongside other departments and with the customer provide information on the organizations culture and processes in addition to tasks.

Overall, the analysis phase of training and performance improvement is extremely important to the success of the intervention.  Without delving into the current and desired state analysis, the Instructional Designer (ID) will not have a clear roadmap of where the organization is and where it wants to get to.  The interventions, whether training, process re-engineering, ergonomics, or some other method, will not provides the turn-by-turn guidance or steps needed to move closer to the desired state.  Both Stolovitch (2002) and Noe (2010) stress the importance of understanding where you are and where you want to be.  Without analysis of people, culture, and process you won’t be able to select the correct intervention appropriate to the situation (Noe, 2010; Beach, 2005).  In training, there is no “one size fits all” solution.  Careful analysis is needed to obtain beneficial results.

References

Beach, L. (2005).  Leadership and the Art of Change:  A practical Guide to Organizational Transformation.  Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

Leib, J.  (2010). “Southwest Airlines hustles to reduce turnaround times”.  The Denver Post.  Retrieved July 5, 2011 from http://www.denverpost.com/news/ci_16175981

Morrison, G. R., Ross, S. M., & Kemp, J. E. (2007). Designing effective instruction (5th ed.). San Francisco, CA: John Wiley and Sons, Inc.

Noe, R. A. (2010). Employee training and development (5th ed.). New York, NY: McGraw Hill. 

Southwest Airlines.  Website retrieved July 5, 2011 from www.iflyswa.com
 
Stolovitch, H. D., and Keeps, E. J. (2002). Telling ain’t training. Alexandria, VA: ASTD Press.

Thursday, June 30, 2011

EIDT 6501 Training Speech

For EIDT 6501, training and Development, I was asked to come up with a speech that explained why training was important and complex and how it could help a business.  Click on the video below or follow this link to hear my speech on VoiceThread: voicethread.com/share/818118/ 

Training is a worthwhile investment when planned and executed properly.  An organization should train to their goals, strategies, and competencies desired in employees.  Training is more than instructing others to mimic the steps necessary to complete a task or process.  It provides skills necessary to think and react to anomalies that may occur throughout the process of completing the task.

With continuous training, employees can develop new skills, refine current skills, and adapt to changing environments.  This helps the company remain competitive and potentially reduce lay-offs in an ever-changing environment.

To execute training properly, a systematic approach using ADDIE or similar method should be used.  ADDIE is an acronym for Analyze, Design, Develop, Implement, and Evaluate.  Special attention should be placed on the analyze phase to ensure both the learners and business' needs are met.  Another commonly overlooked phase is the evaluation of training.  In it, the questions of: are the learners able to apply the knowledge and lessons taught, is the training relevant to the current needs, and does the training support the business long-term and short-term needs should be asked.

As you can tell, training is a complex process that helps businesses remain competitive and obtain their goals.

Sunday, February 13, 2011

Changing Thoughts, Once Again


Officer Jayme Biendl's memorial service was last Tuesday.  Unfortunately, I wasn't able to attend and show support not only to her memory, but to my friends who worked alongside her.  Her death was a shock to me, even though I never met her.  Several of my friends work with her, and they were very shaken up by the events.  But it also makes me wonder about what happens if James' killers are found guilty next month.

There is no death penalty in the state the trial is located.  I used to think the worst punishment for a 16 and 18 year old was to have them in jail for the rest of their lives, with no chance of parole.  Let them think about their actions for the rest of their lives knowing that they will never see freedom again.  I know from my friends who work in the Department of Corrections that county jail is much worse than prison, which is the only reason I am glad the trial was delayed a month.  But the tragic events of Jayme's death highlighted the differences and really cast a shadow of doubt on my beliefs.  The suspect in Jayme's death is a man who was found guilty of rape three times, and under my state's 3 Strikes rule, received life without parole.  Because of his good behavior, he was downgraded to medium security and was allowed privileges within the prison.


So what happens to the two suspects in James' murder if they are found guilty?  Will they be allowed privileges and freedom to move around the prison unsupervised?  Will they think it's all fun and games and have no cares in the world?  Or will they sit, alone, depressed, reliving the night they decided to take some one's life and wishing they could change their actions?  Of course, I want to believe they will be miserable and relieve the night constantly, feeling despair over their actions and the remainder of their lives.  But I'm not so sure that's what happens.


I am disappointed to have missed Jayme's service.  My friends who worked with her know I wanted to be there to show support to her family, friends, and coworkers.  I remember the morning after she was found dead and the phone calls I received to check on my friends.  Thankfully, when I heard the news I knew it wasn't them because they had been out with me the night before.  But I felt their shock and disbelief later in the day when I saw them.  I wish there was something I could have done for them, but having been there so recently myself, I know all I can do is listen when they are ready to talk and be patient with them as they process their emotions in whatever way necessary.  And the one thing they don't know is how much this event has affected me, my thoughts, and my grieving process.

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Scope Creep

A few posts ago, I shared a project from hell titled Change Fail, where nothing seemed to go right.  This week I've been asked to write about scope creep and that same project on waste contains elements of what I've been asked to share.  If you recall, one of the issues involved with customers adding more requirements to the project after a charter and project deliverables had been defined.  Unfortunately, it was a project I was "in charge" of, but my manager retained the project manager, sponsor AND champion positions.  In essence I was only executing what he told me to and arguing or offering a different point of view was looked down upon.  He went as far to tell me that he knows best and if I didn't do as he asked, my performance review would be affected.  What a nice guy, eh?

Background
As part of the project, one of the deliverables was a report to categorize and summarize the waste by product run.  A report was designed with input from the stakeholders and agreed to.  The proof-of-concept showed the same view and data fields the final product would show.  The only difference was the data displayed on the report was fictitious at the time since automated data capture was not available.  Even with fictitious data, we kept the numbers in a reasonable and realistic range to mimic reality.  However, once the report was approximately halfway completed, the stakeholders decided it was no longer good enough for them and wanted additional capabilities in the report such as report by individual operator.  They went as far as to tell us that they would not trust the report until it contained the information they requested and I would be personally running the reports by hand until they could get the report they wanted.  To run each report manually, it took approximately 5 hours per product per piece of equipment.  There were five winders included in the report, and each winder could potentially change product once a day.


Reasons for Creep
A 1994 article in Computerworld lists the top five reasons for scope creep:  poor initial requirements definition, new applications (technology) were unfamiliar to users, projects take too long, failure to manage user expectations, and failure to involve users in early stages.  Unfortunately, I do not feel that any of these reasons were the reasons why the scope kept changing.  At the very start of the project, the people requesting the changes were involved in bi-weekly meetings.  They were provided with an example report that would be automated for them.  The report contained the exact format and data they would receive on a monthly basis and they were given an opportunity to make changes as needed.  After they signed off on the full-scale development of the report, they began changing the requirements and questioning the usefulness of the report.  I honestly and full-heartedly believe we involved the users at the start of the project (every report and data field was approved by them), managed user expectations and provided specific requirements definition by providing an exact replica of the report.  When asked why they wanted to change to report, they were unable to state a clear reason why it was necessary and were not able to provide proof the new requirements were being reported or utilized at present.  The stakeholders were also not able to state how the newly defined requirements would be used to monitor performance of the department.

The reason I believe the stakeholders kept changing the requirements and providing unclear and unrealistic demands was due to change resistance.  They were dragging their feet and delaying the project to avoid being monitored and measured on waste.  Portny et al (2008) point out that upset clients are a common result of creep due to the additional time or cost associated with the project.   Since the report was being provided free of charge to them, the only item they could complain about was the delay.  Never once did they mention the delay or ask when the project would be complete, which supports my feeling that they did not want to implement the waste tracking system.  Beach’s book, Leadership and the Art of Change (2006) also substantiated my belief that it was a resistance to change that caused scope creep and additional requirements.  Unfortunately, the project manager/champion/sponsor never used any method or process to control the project changes or attitudes.  Every suggestion I made to help control the scope and provide realistic reports and time-lines was ignored by him.  By ignoring the requests and not offering any acknowledgment of the requested changes, frustration levels grew between the stakeholders and myself since it appeared that no one was listening to anyone.


Methods for Controlling Creep
Had I been allowed to proceed in my proposed way, I feel the frustration could have been reduced.  Some suggestions to managing scope creep included:
  • Referring back to the original project time-line and agreements 
  • Explaining the impact of the changes
  • Requiring the stakeholders to demonstrate how the information would be used
  • Demonstrating how the requirement was currently being met in a separate report (which was one of the claims)
  • Maintaining a change log or scope creep document
  • Speaking with the stakeholders’ management team 
  • Just saying "NO" and backing it with a valid reason 
Each of these suggestions can be backed in literature including Portny et al (2008), Anthes (1994), and Gurlen (2003).  In the end, the stakeholders agreed to a spiral development approach where we improved the report at distinct intervals once we proved the basic report was accurate.  However, they would not agree to using the report until it was 100% complete according to their opinion.

End Result
The project had a happy end for me after all!  I decided to leave the company, partly due to my management and the way the company managed this project.  OK, who am I kidding? That was a major part of my decision.  On a serious note, a year after the project started, it is still on-going and is not much further along than 6 months ago, even though I've only been gone for 3 months.  I occasionally receive phone calls from my replacement asking for my help or trying to understand the people, attitudes, and agreements in place.  In reality, a project like this should have taken 3 months to complete.  I have worked much more complex projects in shorter time, including dealing with people resistant to change.  The lack of support and direction from the project manager/sponsor/champion was a major cause of the delay and frustrations.  Had he stepped in and been more firm regarding the changes, the project would have progressed faster.
The types of problems encountered in this project was typical of many other projects at the site.  I believe the resistance to change and inability to properly manage projects has already had a large negative impact on the site.  Just the other week they announced additional layoffs and a potential sale of the facility.  In the event they don't find a buyer, they stated they will close the facility.
               
References

Anthes, Gary H.  (1994, May). No more creeps! Computerworld, 28(18), 107.  Retrieved February 10, 2011, from ABI/INFORM Global. (Document ID: 311539).

Beach, L.R. (2006). Leadership and the Art of Change. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc.

Gurlen, S. (2003)  Scope Creep.  Retrieved February 10, 2011 from http://www.umsl.edu/~sauterv/analysis/6840_f03_papers/gurlen/

Portny, S. E., Mantel, S. J., Meredith, J. R., Shafer, S. M., Sutton, M. M., & Kramer, B. E. (2008). Project management: Planning, scheduling, and controlling projects. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Project Management

Project managers can have it tough sometimes.  They are being asked to plan a project, complete with cost and resource estimates, sometimes in an area they are not too familiar with.  On top of the planning, they have to act like an orchestra conductor (Laureate, 2011) to ensure the project progresses forward and success is achieved.  But don't fret, there are some tools and websites that can help you with project estimation, which to me, can be one of the hardest parts of management.

PMI (http://www.pmi.org/), the site for Project Management Institute is where I go first to check for help, advice, and resources on project management.  PMI is the certifying body for PM, and their site contains the Body of Knowledge (BOK) for project managers, professional development section, and knowledge center.  The knowledge center features many articles on a variety of PM topics.  The only downside to this site is some of the articles and areas are restricted access to PMI members only.  But that doesn't mean you can't find great information and help on topics like budget estimation and resource planning.  One of the most helpful and free items to me is BOK.  The BOK often helps me research the proper term that I need help and assistance with.  Because terminology changes from company to company and discipline to discipline, the BOK triggers me with specific words I should include in my searches for help.  If you are lucky enough to have a membership, there are many articles written by SME on cost control, project estimation, and scheduling.  The articles include informative information, white papers, and case studies which have all been reviewed by a panel to ensure they further and advance project management thinking.

All About Project Management (http://managementhelp.org/plan_dec/project/project.htm) is a great resource to have in your back pocket.  The site contains many helpful links for the entire project life-cycle, including agile project management, and is overseen by Kevin Lonergan.  Agile project management is commonly found in IT projects, but more and more aspects of agile PM are making it into mainstream PM.  There are some great agile management concepts that the links talk about such as iterative or spiral development, scrum techniques, and visual controls.  The site not only contains links to other resourceful sites, but also to blogs where you can learn from other project managers.  This site is definitely one you should bookmark, as I find myself coming back to it time and time again because of the consolidation of information.

There are also free templates out there to help with project planning, cost and resource allocations.  Microsoft offers a few good project templates for Microsoft Excel products and you can find them by searching on project and/or planning for business.  For cost estimating, Social Signal (http://www.socialsignal.com/blog/alexandra-samuel/how-create-budget-estimates-proposals-and-project-management) has a great article and tools and templates available for download.  An Excel worksheet, with a pretty comprehensive checklist is also available at the following location:  http://www.exinfm.com/excel%20files/Estimating_Template.xls  I find the strength of this template is the checklists is offers at each stage of the project. 

Overall, there are a ton of resources available on the internet as well as your library to get you through any sticky point of a project.  It is difficult to recommend specific sites because each one is specialized to an area of a project and oftentimes an industry:  budgeting, resource allocation, agile management, getting teams to work together, etc.  Each site and template offers it's own strength - you just have to look for it.

References

Laureate Education, Inc. (Producer). (2011). Communicating with Stakeholders [DVD]. In EDUC 6145. Baltimore, MD.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Messages Delivered in Various Modalities


Communication and message interpretation changes with each modality it is delivered in.  For this week’s assignment, we were given the same message delivered three different ways:  email, voicemail, and face-to-face (via video).  The message is in regards to obtaining a missing report that is vital to the originator’s task.  Without the report, the originator is unable to perform their work and provide information by the assigned due date.

The first modality explored is email.  In my opinion, the email was wordy, indirect, and didn’t express the urgent need upfront.  The email opens with a statement that the person may be in a meeting or workshop all day and away from their computer.  This statement means email is not the best choice to communicate with them.  The communication continues asking for the report, but not providing a deadline of when the report is needed.  It is only asked if they could provide an ETA on when it will be complete.  If this was my message to someone I would have began with what was needed in the opening statement and provide a date when the information is due by.  Dr. Stolovitch (Laureate Education Inc, 2010) states that the purpose of a communication needs to be mentioned upfront, and in the first sentence or two if possible.  Because it is assumed the recipient has been away from their desk, the email may be more effective as a follow-up to a face-to-face interaction or a voicemail.  If it was a follow-up, I would have stated that the email was a follow-up to the previous communication. 

The second modality explored was a voice message left for the individual.  The message was the best out of the three explored, but could still be improved.  I felt the voice was lacking emotion and a sense of urgency.  While the voice was not monotone, it did lack inflection and came across as being required to call the individual.  The voice sounded bored and not really interested in obtaining the report.  This could be for several reasons, one of those being that the individual with the late report is always late and the voice is accustomed to having to follow-up on the individual.

The last modality presented was a video representing face-to-face communication.  This was my least favorite of all three communication types viewed in this exercise.  The person looked defeated, sounded uninterested, and had non-verbal gestures that could be viewed as inappropriate.  The individual only gestures when speaking about the late report, which could be interpreted as placing blame on the person they are speaking to.  She also looks away when asking for a ETA or if the report could be sent via email.  This tells me she is not comfortable speaking to this person and requesting information.

Overall, while the message in all three scenarios was the same, I felt the voicemail was the most effective in this scenario.  Major improvements could have taken place in all three examples.  In general, the message was not clear, concise, and focused as Dr. Stolovitch (Laureate Education Inc, 2010) suggested it should be.  Each communication should have started with the purpose and intent of the communication, and included specifics as to what was being requested and by when.  Email and voicemail may have been the wrong choices to communicate with if the person has been gone all day.  Depending on the circumstances, voicemail and/or face-to-face would be my primary choice for communication with email as my last choice.  The choice of words is also important in portraying a message.  The choices used in the examples make the requester come across as unsure, defeated, and uninterested in all examples presented.

Research has been performed on effective communication forms as well as leadership and communication styles.  Gluckler & Schrott (2007) have found that face-to-face communication  is the most effective type of communication form among teams when compared to email and mobile email (smartphone).  Voicemail was not included in the study.  Traditional email (sent via desktop computer versus mobile device) was effective in summarizing meetings, decisions, and communicating to a broader audience that included people who were kept up to date on the team's progress.  Mobile email was by far found to be the least effective for communication in a team setting.  Based on this study, as work published by Allen (1977), effectiveness of communication decreases over distance.  After about 30 feet of separation, the message being communicated becomes distorted and loses impact.  F2F communication is recognized as being the strongest, best, and most effective form of communication.  But as an effective communicator, verbal and non-verbal cues still remain an important part of the message.  As previously mentioned, I preferred voicemail over the F2F message provided in this week's case study.  The non-verbal message the person communicated overshadowed what she was trying to accomplish.  In summary, careful thought must be applied to the message, choice of words, non-verbal message, and mode of communication.  Attention should be paid to the background and personality of the person you are communicating with to ensure it will be an effective fit.

References 

Allen, TJ. (1977). Managing the Flow of Technology: Technology Transfer and the Dissemination of Technological Information Within the R&D Organization.  Boston, MA: The MIT Press.

Gluckler, J. and Schrott, G. (2007). Leadership and Performance in Virtual Teams: Exploring Brokerage in Electronic Communication.  International Journal of e-Collaboration, 3(3), 31.

Laureate Education, Inc. (Producer). (2010). Communicating with Stakeholders [DVD]. In EDUC 6145. Baltimore, MD.